1987 New York Mets: The Shocking Truth Behind Their Failed Repeat Bid

After a thrilling championship season, expectations for the 1987 New York Mets were sky-high. Fans packed Shea Stadium, eagerly anticipating a dominant run and a championship repeat, a feat few teams achieve. Key figures like ace pitcher Dwight Gooden and powerful slugger Darryl Strawberry were expected to lead the charge. Despite their immense talent, a puzzling confluence of factors derailed their bid for another World Series title, leaving many to wonder what truly went wrong with this star-studded roster.

Image taken from the YouTube channel GP videos , from the video titled 1987 Braves at Mets .

Stepping onto the diamond as reigning champions, the 1987 New York Mets carried not just a title, but the immense weight of expectation. After a spectacular 1986 season that culminated in a thrilling World Series victory, the stage was set for what many believed would be the dawn of a baseball dynasty.

The Afterglow of '86 and Unprecedented Hype

The New York Mets entered the highly anticipated 1987 MLB Season as the undisputed kings of baseball. Their 1986 campaign had been nothing short of dominant, with a remarkable 108-54 regular season record – the best in Major League Baseball that year – leading to a hard-fought triumph over the Boston Red Sox in the World Series. This was not just a championship team; it was a vibrant, swaggering roster, featuring charismatic stars like Dwight Gooden, Darryl Strawberry, Keith Hernandez, and Gary Carter. They captivated the city and the nation, embodying a new era of Mets baseball defined by power, pitching, and an undeniable confidence.

The public, the media, and even the team itself brimmed with overwhelming expectations for a sustained period of greatness. Talk of a Mets "dynasty" wasn't merely speculation; it felt like an inevitable prophecy. Analysts lauded their youthful core, depth, and the palpable chemistry that had propelled them to the top. Fans eagerly anticipated a repeat performance, a natural continuation of their dominant ascent. The question wasn't if they would make the MLB Playoffs again, but how many championships this seemingly invincible squad would collect.

A Shocking Reality

Yet, amidst this fervent anticipation, a different narrative was quietly brewing. Despite their talent and the lingering aura of invincibility, the 1987 New York Mets faced a shocking reality that defied all predictions. Their journey, intended to be a victory lap, would instead become a cautionary tale. Against all odds and the enormous pressure of their status, this celebrated team would fall short of the ultimate prize, failing to repeat as champions and ultimately missing the MLB Playoffs entirely. The weight of the crown, it turned out, was heavier than anyone could have imagined.

The immense pressure that weighed on the 1987 New York Mets wasn't solely a byproduct of their 1986 World Series triumph; it was profoundly rooted in the sheer, undeniable talent they possessed. This was a roster that, on paper, read like a fantasy baseball dream, a collection of young phenoms and seasoned veterans seemingly poised for an era of unprecedented dominance.

A Roster Forged for Greatness: The Untapped Potential

Stepping onto the field at Shea Stadium, the 1987 Mets were not just champions; they were a constellation of baseball stars, each shining brightly with individual accolades and collective promise. The belief in a sustained Mets dynasty wasn't mere fan hyperbole; it was built upon a deep foundation of talent that had already delivered one championship and appeared capable of many more.

The Core of a Champion

The roster was a remarkable blend of power, speed, pitching prowess, and veteran leadership. At the forefront were the prodigious talents of Dwight Gooden, the flamethrowing right-hander who had already captured a Cy Young Award in 1985, and Darryl Strawberry, the towering slugger whose effortless power promised countless home runs. Both were still in their early twenties, embodying the youthful exuberance and immense potential of the team.

Complementing these rising stars were the unflappable veteran presence of Keith Hernandez, a multiple Gold Glove winner and former batting champion whose leadership was invaluable, and Gary Carter, the future Hall of Fame catcher whose clutch hitting and infectious enthusiasm had anchored the team. The pitching staff, beyond Gooden, boasted formidable arms in Ron Darling, a consistent performer, and the enigmatic left-hander Sid Fernandez, known for his devastating curveball. Rounding out the staff were reliable southpaw Bobby Ojeda and the fiery reliever Roger McDowell, a crucial arm from the bullpen.

In the outfield, Lenny Dykstra brought a gritty, high-energy style, while Wally Backman provided a scrappy, contact-first approach at second base. Each player, from the certified superstars to the integral role players, contributed to a collective identity of aggressive play and undeniable skill.

Davey Johnson: The Orchestrator of Power

Guiding this powerhouse was manager Davey Johnson. Known for his progressive, analytical approach to the game, Johnson had successfully cultivated a winning environment at Shea Stadium. He empowered his players, fostering a clubhouse culture that, while at times boisterous, was fundamentally geared towards winning. His ability to manage a team packed with outsized personalities and deliver a World Series title in 1986 solidified his reputation as an astute baseball mind, further fueling the expectations for continued success.

Sky-High Expectations: Pitching and Power

The collective potential of this roster led to extraordinary expectations. The pitching rotation was widely regarded as one of the most potent in baseball, a seemingly endless parade of power arms and deceptive movement. The thought of Gooden, Darling, Fernandez, and Ojeda consistently shutting down opposing lineups gave fans and pundits alike reason to believe in perennial contention.

Equally compelling was the team's slugging lineup. With Darryl Strawberry as the primary power threat, complemented by the consistent hitting of Keith Hernandez and the timely pop of Gary Carter, the Mets were expected to put up runs in bunches. This potent combination of dominant pitching and an explosive offense led to widespread predictions of not just another playoff berth, but the forging of a true dynasty. The question wasn't if they would win, but how many championships they would secure in the years to come.

While the 1987 Mets roster shone brightly with undeniable star power and boundless promise, a closer look at the season's nascent stages revealed a narrative far more complex than the dynasty foretold. The early days, rather than solidifying their reign, instead exposed subtle yet significant fissures that would ultimately define their path.

Early Season Unraveling: Cracks in the Foundation

Despite the immense talent and pre-season optimism, the 1987 season for the New York Mets began to show subtle, yet concerning, cracks. This section examines the early struggles that hinted at deeper issues, defying the narrative of an unstoppable champion.

Initial Signs of Struggle

The euphoric glow of the 1986 championship still lingered as the 1987 season began, fueling an almost unprecedented level of hype for the Mets. They were widely considered not just contenders, but a lock for another World Series title, perhaps even the beginning of a dynasty. However, the early weeks offered more than just dominant victories. While the Mets initially burst out of the gate with a strong 10-2 record, a disquieting six-game losing streak in late April and early May quickly brought their record down to 18-13 by May 6th. This sudden stumble, for a team seemingly invincible, served as the first stark contradiction to the pre-season narrative, hinting that their path wouldn't be as smooth as anticipated. Opponents found ways to exploit weaknesses, and the Mets, despite their firepower, seemed to lose some of their unshakeable swagger.

Subtle Shifts in Clubhouse Chemistry

The 1986 Mets were celebrated not just for their on-field prowess, but for their unique, often boisterous, clubhouse chemistry—a blend of fierce competitiveness and tight-knit camaraderie. This dynamic, affectionately dubbed "The Family," was a cornerstone of their success. Yet, in 1987, this vaunted bond began to show signs of strain. What was once seen as playful bravado sometimes edged into internal friction. Stories of individualistic tendencies increasing, coupled with a slight decline in collective focus, started to circulate. The relentless media scrutiny that comes with being a defending champion also amplified any minor disagreements, occasionally transforming competitive banter into genuine tension. The subtle shift meant that the unselfish, unified approach that defined their championship run felt less pronounced, impacting team cohesion in critical moments.

Early Season Injuries Beginning to Test Depth

No team, no matter how talented, is immune to the toll of a long baseball season, and early season injuries began to test the Mets' depth and resilience. While the roster was deep, even minor ailments to key players could disrupt rhythm and create uncertainty. Catcher Gary Carter, a foundational leader and offensive threat, began to feel the effects of persistent knee issues early in the season. While he still played through much of it, his mobility and offensive production, particularly his power, were subtly diminished compared to his peak years. Similarly, first baseman Keith Hernandez, another pivotal veteran presence and offensive linchpin, battled a nagging hamstring issue through spring training and the early part of the regular season, impacting his defensive range and overall comfort. These early physical setbacks, though not always sidelining players completely, forced the team to manage workloads carefully and signaled that the physical demands of defending a title would be a significant challenge.

The early weeks of the 1987 season offered more than just an initial stumble; they were symptomatic of deeper, systemic issues festering beneath the surface of the New York Mets. What appeared as a minor wobble quickly revealed itself as a foundational tremor, fueled by a confluence of critical factors that undermined the team's potential from within.

The Deeper Truths: Factors Behind the Fall

Beneath the surface of a disappointing season lay a complex web of contributing factors that systematically undermined the Mets' potential. This section uncovers the critical, often interconnected, issues that led to their shocking underperformance.

Ailing Arms and Bodies: The Injury Bug Bites Hard

The vaunted Mets pitching staff, a bedrock of their 1986 championship, was particularly hard hit, significantly impacting the team's overall strength and consistency. Ace Dwight Gooden, whose arm had seemed invincible, battled shoulder issues that affected his velocity and command, a stark contrast to his dominant Cy Young form. While he still managed 15 wins, his 3.52 ERA was the highest of his young career up to that point, signaling a clear dip in his previously unassailable performance.

Likewise, Ron Darling, another key starter, contended with persistent elbow pain throughout the season. This often forced him to pitch through discomfort, affecting his effectiveness and contributing to an ERA of 4.29—nearly a full run higher than his 1986 mark. These setbacks, coupled with other nagging injuries across the roster, severely tested the team's depth and resilience, forcing managers to rely on less experienced or less effective replacements at critical junctures. The once-formidable pitching rotation was simply not as sharp or as healthy as it needed to be to withstand the rigors of a full season.

Cracks in the Facade: Clubhouse Chemistry Deteriorates

The tight-knit camaraderie that had characterized the 1986 championship squad began to fray in 1987. Internal conflicts, ego clashes, and a perceived decline in cohesion systematically eroded the once-solid clubhouse chemistry. Veterans like Keith Hernandez, the team's respected captain and intellectual leader, found his influence challenged by a new dynamic within the locker room. The youthful exuberance and unified focus that had propelled them to a title seemed to dissipate, replaced by individual frustrations and a noticeable lack of collective drive.

This shift was particularly evident in star players like Darryl Strawberry. While immensely talented, his growing impatience and sometimes volatile temperament reportedly contributed to an atmosphere of tension, especially as the team struggled to recapture its winning ways. What was once a unified front became a collection of highly skilled individuals, each navigating their own challenges, but increasingly less connected as a cohesive unit. The internal friction became an unwelcome distraction, impacting performance on the field.

A Pervasive Shadow: The Impact of Drug Use

Beyond the physical ailments and interpersonal strife, a more insidious challenge lurked within baseball during the 1980s: the pervasive presence of substance abuse. While often a private struggle, its potential, often unseen, impact on player consistency, decision-making, and the overall atmosphere within the New York Mets clubhouse cannot be understated. This era in MLB history was marked by numerous high-profile cases of drug use, and the Mets, like other teams, were not immune to its pervasive shadow.

The insidious nature of substance abuse meant it didn't always manifest as overt failures, but rather as subtle erosions of discipline, focus, and reliability. It could affect a player's ability to maintain peak physical condition, hinder their mental sharpness in high-pressure situations, or contribute to a general sense of fatigue and detachment. This underlying issue, combined with other factors, created an unstable foundation that chipped away at the team's professional focus and potentially exacerbated existing tensions within the club.

Falling Short of the Mark: Widespread Underperformance

Despite the immense talent on the roster, the 1987 season was marked by critical instances of underperformance across key areas and by crucial players. While the team still put up respectable numbers, they frequently fell short of the high expectations set for them.

Gary Carter, the beloved "Kid" and a linchpin of the Mets' offense and defense, saw a noticeable dip in his offensive production. His home run total dropped from 24 in 1986 to 20 in 1987, and his batting average dipped, indicating a general decline in the consistent, clutch hitting expected from him.

Even Darryl Strawberry, despite hitting an impressive 39 home runs and driving in 104 runs, displayed an inconsistency at the plate that often frustrated fans and coaches alike. He led the league with 137 strikeouts and often seemed to battle mental lapses or moments of uninspired play that belied his prodigious talent. These individual shortcomings, when combined with a collective inability to perform consistently in crucial situations or against top-tier pitching, contributed significantly to the Mets' surprising failure to replicate their previous season's dominance.

While internal factors certainly chipped away at the Mets' foundation, their 1987 fate was also inextricably linked to a relentless external force: the St. Louis Cardinals. The season wasn't just a battle against their own shortcomings; it was a grueling, head-to-head slugfest for the National League East crown, a contest that ultimately determined who would advance to October.

The National League East Gauntlet: Mets vs. Cardinals

Even as the Mets grappled with injuries, clubhouse friction, and underperformance, they remained locked in a tenacious struggle with the St. Louis Cardinals throughout the 1987 season. This wasn't merely a division race; it was a captivating narrative of two titans exchanging blows, with every game carrying immense weight. The Cardinals, known for their speed and aggressive baserunning under manager Whitey Herzog, proved to be an incredibly resilient and frustrating opponent for the Mets' power-heavy lineup and dominant pitching staff.

A Season-Long Tug-of-War

From spring training's hopeful dawn to the autumn's chilly end, the NL East race between New York and St. Louis was a veritable tug-of-war. The Mets, despite their struggles, held first place for much of the season, often by razor-thin margins. However, they could never quite shake the persistent Cardinals. Every time the Mets seemed poised to pull away, St. Louis would respond, fueled by key players like shortstop Ozzie Smith, outfielder Vince Coleman, and first baseman Jack Clark, who hit a crucial 35 home runs that year. The constant pressure from their rival meant the Mets had little room for error, amplifying the stress of their internal issues.

Pivotal Battles at Shea Stadium

The drama of the division race often culminated in high-stakes matchups at Shea Stadium. While the Mets' overall home record was strong, key series against the Cardinals proved decisive. A particularly critical series unfolded in mid-September. The Mets entered that showdown holding a slim lead, but the Cardinals arrived in Flushing on a hot streak. St. Louis took the series, including a pivotal 7-4 victory on September 11th, to seize control of the division lead. These head-to-head clashes at Shea were not just games; they were heavyweight bouts, with each pitch and swing capable of shifting momentum in a championship pursuit. The atmosphere was electric, but ultimately, the Cardinals frequently found ways to leave Shea with the upper hand.

The Inability to Pull Away

What truly defined the Mets' external struggle in 1987 was their consistent inability to pull away from the Cardinals. Despite flashes of brilliance, like Dwight Gooden's 15 wins or Darryl Strawberry's 39 home runs, the team could never build a comfortable cushion. The Cardinals' tenacious play meant that even a minor Mets stumble could cost them significant ground. By the end of September, St. Louis had established a lead they would not relinquish. The Cardinals ultimately clinched the National League East title by a margin of three games, finishing with a record of 95-67 to the Mets' 92-70. This narrow defeat, after a season of relentless pursuit, was a bitter pill, underscoring how deeply the external pressure of a formidable rival contributed to the Mets' ultimate fall from grace.

After a season-long tussle with the St. Louis Cardinals, a relentless pursuit that had defined their 1987 campaign, the New York Mets found themselves not celebrating a hard-won division title, but confronting a far more bitter truth. The gauntlet had been run, but the ultimate prize slipped through their fingers, leaving behind a profound sense of disappointment for the defending champions.

The Bitter End: Missing October's Stage

As the calendar pages turned to September, the relentless back-and-forth atop the National League East reached its grim crescendo. What began as a hopeful defense of their championship title slowly, agonizingly, eroded into a stark reality: the dream of a repeat would not materialize. The final weeks of the 1987 MLB Season became a test of endurance and, ultimately, a public reckoning for the New York Mets.

The Slipping Grip on the NL East

The race for the National League East Division crown remained incredibly tight deep into September. The St. Louis Cardinals, fueled by timely hitting and stellar pitching, consistently found ways to counter every Mets surge. While the Mets pushed valiantly, their efforts were often matched, or slightly eclipsed, by their determined rivals. Heading into the final week of the season, the gap, though small, felt insurmountable. The Cardinals held a precarious but persistent lead, forcing the Mets into a must-win scenario with little margin for error.

Despite the Mets' own respectable 92-win season, it simply wasn't enough to overcome the Cardinals' 95 victories. The division title, which had felt within reach for so long, officially belonged to St. Louis.

The Inevitable Knockout

The painful moment of mathematical elimination arrived on September 27, 1987. While the Mets were on the road, battling the Philadelphia Phillies, their fate was sealed elsewhere. The St. Louis Cardinals defeated the Montreal Expos, clinching the National League East Division title outright. For the New York Mets, the loss to the Phillies that day became secondary; the broader, more crushing reality was that their path to the MLB Playoffs had officially been blocked.

It was a somber conclusion for a team that had battled so ferociously. The hopes that had fueled a demanding 162-game schedule were extinguished, not with a dramatic collapse, but with the quiet, definitive click of a division race concluded.

A Champion's Unfulfilled Promise

The collective disappointment was palpable. Just one year prior, the 1986 World Series Champions had stood atop the baseball world, reveling in their hard-earned glory. The expectation for 1987 was not merely to compete, but to contend fiercely for another championship. To fall short, especially after such a grueling and competitive season, was a shock that reverberated throughout the clubhouse and through the fanbase.

The season ended not with a champagne celebration, but with a quiet retreat into the offseason, forcing a deep reflection on what went wrong and how a team with so much talent and recent success could miss October's grand stage entirely. For the Mets and their passionate followers, the "Bitter End" was indeed a hard pill to swallow.

As the final out of the 1987 season settled, sealing the Mets' fate outside of October's spotlight, a different kind of challenge emerged: the painstaking process of understanding how. The euphoria of 1986 had faded into the bitter taste of missed opportunity, leaving behind a bewildering question that demanded a forensic examination.

Post-Mortem: Unpacking the Unthinkable

In the aftermath of a season that defied all expectations, yet tragically not in the desired direction, a thorough and painful examination was inevitable. This was not merely a disappointing finish; it was the stunning collapse of a team widely considered to be on the precipice of a dynasty. A comprehensive post-mortem was crucial, synthesizing the myriad reasons behind the New York Mets' astonishing failure to make the MLB Playoffs, offering a sobering look at a season derailed.

The Multifaceted Unraveling

The "failed repeat bid" of the 1987 Mets wasn't attributable to a single cataclysmic event, but rather a perfect storm of compounding issues. What unfolded was a complex narrative of talent undermined by circumstance, internal strife, and personal demons.

One significant factor was the pervasive impact of injuries. Catcher Gary Carter, the team's veteran leader and heart, battled a knee injury that visibly sapped his power and limited his starts, ultimately requiring surgery. First baseman Keith Hernandez, another crucial clubhouse presence and offensive anchor, struggled with back issues that contributed to a decline in his offensive production. Even superstars like Darryl Strawberry faced nagging shoulder and hand ailments that, while not sidelining him entirely, hampered his consistency and explosive power throughout the long season. These physical tolls chipped away at the team's depth and collective performance, leaving key players operating at less than 100%.

Beyond the physical, the once-unbreakable clubhouse chemistry began to show significant cracks. The boisterous, confident swagger that defined the 1986 champions seemed to curdle into infighting and discontent. What was once viewed as healthy competitiveness morphed into distinct cliques and simmering tensions. Reports from within suggested a growing lack of cohesion, a sense that the team's vibrant personalities were no longer pulling in the same direction. The unifying force that propelled them to a World Series crown appeared to dissolve, replaced by an unsettling undercurrent of discord.

Perhaps the most devastating and publicly acknowledged blow came from the shadow of drug use. Star pitcher Dwight Gooden, the phenom who had mesmerized baseball just a few years prior, entered a rehabilitation facility in June 1987 for substance abuse. His absence was not just a gaping hole in the pitching rotation but a profound emotional and psychological blow to the entire organization. The private struggles of one of the team's most beloved figures cast a pall over the clubhouse, serving as a stark reminder of the pressures and temptations that permeated the sport at the time. Gooden's personal battle underscored a larger, unspoken issue that undoubtedly contributed to the team's overall instability.

Collectively, these factors led to widespread underperformance across the roster. While the Mets still managed a respectable 92-70 record, it felt like a significant underachievement given the talent on hand and the towering expectations set by their 1986 triumph. Their team ERA rose from 3.11 in 1986 to 3.51 in 1987, and while their batting average remained consistent, the timely hitting and dominant pitching that characterized their championship season were often absent in crucial moments. They simply weren't consistent enough to overcome a relentless St. Louis Cardinals squad that finished three games ahead, securing the National League East Division title with 95 wins.

Leadership's View: Johnson and Cashen Reflect

For manager Davey Johnson, the season was a perplexing tightrope walk, balancing the demands of winning with the mounting off-field distractions. Johnson, known for his calm, analytical approach, often spoke publicly about the need for focus, implicitly acknowledging the internal issues plaguing his squad. Privately, he grappled with a team that, despite its immense talent, lacked the same unwavering discipline and singular purpose that defined their championship run. He later lamented the external pressures and internal rifts that seemed to chip away at the team's collective will, suggesting the cohesiveness of 1986 was largely absent.

General Manager Frank Cashen, the architect of the dominant roster, faced the stark reality that even the most talented collection of players could falter. His perspective likely centered on the unforeseen variables—the injuries that decimated key positions and the personal challenges that derailed integral players. Cashen, a shrewd baseball mind, had assembled a team designed for sustained success. The 1987 unraveling, therefore, represented a significant strategic setback, one that forced a re-evaluation of not just player performance but the overall environment fostering such a high-profile, high-pressure team.

The Shocking Truth: Talent Derailed

The "shocking truth" re-emphasized in this post-mortem is not merely that a highly talented team failed to make the MLB Playoffs, but how such a promising dynasty could be derailed so swiftly and comprehensively. A roster boasting MVPs, Cy Young winners, and future Hall of Famers—including Dwight Gooden, Darryl Strawberry, Keith Hernandez, Gary Carter, Ron Darling, and Sid Fernandez—was supposed to dominate for years. Instead, the 1987 season exposed the fragility of success, demonstrating that even immense talent and sky-high expectations could be undone by a toxic brew of injuries, fractured clubhouse dynamics, and deeply personal struggles. It was a stark, painful lesson in the complexities of professional sports, where the human element often dictates the ultimate outcome, regardless of the glittering names on the lineup card.

Ultimately, the story of the 1987 New York Mets remains a compelling narrative of unfulfilled potential in baseball history. While their quest for another title fell short, their impact on the era is undeniable.