NYC Pizza Menu Secrets: Order Like a Local!

in Information
6 minutes on read

Embark on a culinary journey into the heart of New York City’s pizza scene! The crispy crust, a hallmark of a true New York slice, starts with a perfect dough recipe, which is often considered sacred. From the classic Margherita available on almost every new york pizza menu, to the unique creations at iconic pizzerias like Lombardi's, variety is the name of the game. Whether you're a seasoned foodie or a first-time visitor eager to decode a new york pizza menu, this guide to the anatomy of a slice will transform you from tourist to local.

Keith Eats Every Pizza in NYC

Image taken from the YouTube channel The Try Guys , from the video titled Keith Eats Every Pizza in NYC .

Decoding the New York Pizza Menu: Order Like a Local!

This guide unveils the secrets to navigating a new york pizza menu like a seasoned New Yorker. Forget tourist traps and order like a true local with this inside knowledge.

Understanding the Basics: Slices, Pies, and More

First, familiarize yourself with the fundamental terms. Knowing these will help you decipher any new york pizza menu and avoid confusion.

Slice vs. Pie

  • Slice: A single, usually triangular, portion of a whole pizza. Expect a classic, thin-crust slice unless otherwise specified.
  • Pie: An entire pizza. Typically, a standard pie is 8 slices, but this can vary depending on the pizzeria.

Common Crust Styles

Crust Style Description Common on Menu?
Regular Standard thin crust, the most common type found in NYC. Yes
Sicilian Thick, rectangular crust; often baked in a pan and topped with sauce first. Yes
Neapolitan Soft, airy crust with charred spots; requires a wood-fired oven. Increasingly
Grandma Similar to Sicilian, but thinner and crispier. Sometimes

Key Pizza Menu Terminology

  • Plain: Simply cheese pizza, usually mozzarella.
  • Toppings: These can range from classic pepperoni to more elaborate vegetable combinations.
  • Half-and-Half: Ordering a pie with different toppings on each half. Common but confirm availability.
  • Well-Done: Requesting the pizza to be cooked longer, resulting in a crispier crust.
  • Upside-Down: Sauce is applied before the cheese (common for Sicilian style).

The new york pizza menu can seem simple, but subtle nuances can enhance your experience.

Essential Toppings

  • Pepperoni: The king of pizza toppings, almost always available.
  • Sausage: Usually Italian sausage, either crumbled or in links.
  • Mushrooms: Button mushrooms are the standard, but some pizzerias offer other varieties.
  • Onions: Typically white onions, sliced or diced.
  • Peppers: Bell peppers, usually green, but red and yellow options might be available.
  • Olives: Black or green olives, often pitted.

Unlocking the Specialty Pie Section

The "Specialty Pies" section is where you'll find creative and regionally-inspired options on a new york pizza menu.

  • Margherita: A classic Neapolitan pie with tomato sauce, mozzarella, and basil.
  • White Pizza: Made with ricotta cheese, mozzarella, garlic, and olive oil – no tomato sauce.
  • Vegetarian: Varies by pizzeria but typically includes a selection of vegetables like spinach, broccoli, and peppers.
  • Meat Lover's: A carnivore's dream, loaded with various meats like pepperoni, sausage, and bacon.
  • Buffalo Chicken: Topped with buffalo chicken, blue cheese dressing, and mozzarella.

Advanced Ordering Techniques: Order Like a Pro

Elevate your new york pizza menu skills with these insider tips.

You also like
NJ to NY Commute: Your Ultimate Guide [Must Read!]
  1. Know your pizzeria: Different places specialize in different styles. Research online reviews to find your perfect match.
  2. Ask about "off-menu" options: Some pizzerias have secret items or custom creations they don't advertise.
  3. Order "Grandma-style": Even if it's not on the new york pizza menu, if the place does Sicilian pies, they might be willing to make a "Grandma" upon request (thin crust, pan-baked Sicilian).
  4. Consider the time of day: Some places offer special lunch slices or happy hour deals.
  5. Don't be afraid to customize: Ask for extra sauce, specific cheese, or a combination of toppings that aren't listed. Just be prepared for potential upcharges.

Beyond the Pizza: Drinks and Sides

A new york pizza menu typically includes beverages and a few side dishes.

Classic Drinks

  • Soda: Coke, Pepsi, and other common soft drinks are staples.
  • Iced Tea: Unsweetened or sweetened varieties.
  • Water: Bottled or tap water is usually available.
  • Italian Ices: A refreshing treat, especially during warmer months.
  • Garlic Knots: Doughy knots baked with garlic, olive oil, and herbs.
  • Zeppoles: Fried dough balls dusted with powdered sugar.
  • Calzones and Strombolis: Savory pastries filled with cheese, meat, and vegetables.

Video: NYC Pizza Menu Secrets: Order Like a Local!

23 New York Pizza Slices in 36 Hours. Which is the Best? | Bon Appétit

NYC Pizza Menu Secrets: FAQs

Here are some frequently asked questions about ordering pizza in NYC like a local. This should help you navigate any new york pizza menu with confidence.

You also like
NYC to Nashville Flights: The Ultimate Guide [MUST READ]

What's the difference between a regular slice and a Sicilian slice?

A regular slice is the classic triangular piece of thin-crust pizza. A Sicilian slice is a thick, rectangular piece, usually with a spongier dough and a bolder sauce. You'll find both on virtually every new york pizza menu.

What does "well-done" mean when ordering pizza?

Ordering your pizza "well-done" means you want it cooked longer, resulting in a crispier crust and slightly browned cheese. It's a common request to ensure your new york pizza experience is just right.

What are some common toppings I should know about?

Besides the basics, look for toppings like pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, peppers, and olives. Some places offer more unique options like eggplant or artichoke hearts. Knowing what's available on the new york pizza menu helps you personalize your pie.

You also like
NY Actors: How They're Changing the Industry!

What's the deal with white pizza?

White pizza (or "pizza bianca") is made without tomato sauce, typically using ricotta, mozzarella, garlic, olive oil, and sometimes other cheeses or toppings. It's a great alternative to the traditional red-sauce new york pizza menu option.

You also like
Rochester to NYC: Is the Drive Worth It? You Won't Believe!
So, grab your appetite, head to your favorite spot, and order with confidence! You're now ready to navigate any new york pizza menu like a true New Yorker. Enjoy!